Should the smoking ban be lifted?

15 October 2010

The debate about the smoking ban has been reopened by an MP's attempt to introduce a bill to exempt pubs and clubs from the blanket ban, and give private members' clubs the option to have a smoking room.

What do you think?

  • Should the ban introduced in all public places across the UK in 2007 be lifted, as long as pubs and clubs have self-contained smoking rooms?
  • Or are you happy to socialise in smoke-free areas and support the ban on smoking in public places?

What is your view on this? Have your say, and debate the issue here on PCS comment, a selection of the comments will be published in View, the monthly magazine for PCS members.

Please note that we reserve the right to edit any contribution before publication. We do not guarantee that all contributions will be published.

Tab Comment

  1. View comments
  2. Add a new comment

Tab Comment content

  1. Light up for a more tolerant future

    18 October 2010

    Smokers are so, so cold now after four years of smoking outside, the old mantra of 'smokers die younger' could end up becoming true, but not because of smoking-related diseases. We need a common sense approach where everyone's choices are catered for and not just the few. The old approach of smoking in the bar and not smoking in the lounge in pubs seemed to work quite well and a pint without a fag just aint the same. If we were trying to be health conscious we wouldn't be in the pub in the first place.

    Marcus Ford
    Let's have joined up thinking

    18 October 2010

    I think we should lift the ban on smoking in public places, including bars, clubs, resturaunts, churches, hospitals and schools. This is an issue of personal freedom and choice and if people want to poison themselves, that is their business. Anyway, the extra taxes they pay on tobacco products will pay the additional costs to the NHS until they die. Then the undertakers get their share. In line with this new-found sense of personal liberty, I also think we should legalise and open opium dens, as in the good old days of Sherlock Holmes and Moriarty. Again, if you don't want to take it, don't go there. The same goes for marijuana, skunk and crack cocaine. No one forces you to become an addict and all this wingeing about secondary effects like drug-related crime and social deprivation is just more big government, instead of big society. And while we're about it, what about doping in sport? We'd soon see a few more medals if our athletes were allowed to reach their full potential.

    Dan Tanzey
    NO

    18 October 2010

    The danger of secondary smoking is not a myth and is a genuine threat to health which is why the ban was introduced in the first place. In addition, privately-owned pubs and clubs are still required to comply with health and safety regulations. If people wish to carry on smoking that is up to them, but I would prefer it if they did not put a strain on the resources of our already over-burdened NHS when they develop cancer, bronchitis, and other chest and blood pressure problems.

    Lin Black
    Choice is king

    18 October 2010

    It's all about giving choices and empowering the pub industry to decide for themselves if they want a smoking ban or not. It should have always been up to the landlord if they wanted to ban smoking, not the government.

    David Sheffield
    Allow publicans to decide

    18 October 2010

    If a publican wants to allow people to smoke in their bar then they should be allowed to make the decision. Equally if they do not want a smoking pub they should be allowed to ban it, that way everyone is happy. Non-smokers could go to a non-smoking bar, while smokers go to a bar where they can smoke. It allows each individual to make an informed choice on where they wish to go.

    maryjane connelly
    First Previous | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | Next Last
  2. Add new comment

    All comments will be moderated before publication. PCS does not guarantee that all comments will be published. Please see our comments policy for more information.

Tab Bottom

  1. Directory
  2. Contact Us